
Question: Hey everyone! I’ve been noticing the political landscape globally for the past week, and it seems like there is a growing trend toward right-wing politicians.
For example, Argentina, Netherlands, Finland, Israel, Sweden and many more. This isn’t limited to one region but appears to be worldwide phenomenon.
What might be causing that shift?
Best Answer
One generally applicable principle for Western democratic politics is that when the world is relatively stable, there is added room for liberal thought in politics. It’s almost as if to say “things are going well, we have the green light to experiment with ways to make society better.”
Western democratic societies tend to lean conservative when things get more unstable. Shaky economic outlook, threat of war abroad, etc. tend to drive a society to the right.
There are, of course, specific nuances applicable to each country where this is occurring. But the general theme of the 2020s so far for the West has been: “take care of your own and what you have,” which tends to be more closely-reflected in right-wing politics than it is in traditionally more “open” left-wing politics (in Western democracies).
Of course, many will argue that this is all contingent upon how you define “right-wing.” Some argue we’re just shifting a bit to the right inside of a holistic left-wing skew (and still more may argue we’re in a holistic right-wing skew), but this isn’t generally how it is thought of within the West.
Another answer
Typically immigration is one of many issues upon which a Western voter might cast their vote, but it generally isn’t the main concern. In most instances, however, it is a primary concern among many others. That said, it generally isn’t a “sticky” enough issue at a voting booth to be the main driver for a voter’s choice.
All of the above said, immigration directly feeds into “hard” discussions surrounding the economy and national security. For example: are there jobs for immigrants? How many of them are skilled versus unskilled? Educated versus uneducated? Do they speak English (or the local language)? How would they slot into the local education system? Do they harbor views that are antithetical to the local culture or value system? Are they from a war-torn area where extremism is common? Do they have prior criminal records? Did they migrate “legally” (in a documented manner), or did they “jump” the border / overstay their visa? Are they paying taxes? Should we strictly enforce deportation of “illegal” / undocumented migrants, or should there be a path to “forgiveness” and citizenship? These are just a few sample questions, among many others.
It also becomes a “soft” cultural discussion, where there is a general sense that unfettered immigration is a threat to the ideological integrity and relative unity of an established society. If country X is largely democratic and accepts 500,000 immigrants from country Y, a largely authoritarian society, there might be issues with integration. These issues are compounded where there is a mismatch with respect to religious beliefs, language, and customs. Failed integration of migrants is historically a “poison pill” for democracies.
Because so many different people from different backgrounds, cultures, and belief systems are constantly migrating to the West, a coherent policy that accounts for these differences is considered to be quite difficult to implement and, clearly, becomes very quickly politically divisive. In more uncertain times, this discussion trends towards a traditionally more right-wing “protectionist” ideology. In the US, it often forms part of the “isolationist” ideology, a historically common trend here that promotes non-intervention in foreign affairs and, usually, stricter limitations on immigration.
Another answer
I thought about this when Trump was elected.
The voters who swing to the right during certain time periods often has legit grievances, which are not being addressed, or being addressed too slowly by the existing establishment parties, whether that's left wing or right wing.
Then all of a sudden, someone comes out, points out an easy, foreign target (arab migrants, blacks, mexicans, jews, or Japan in the 80s, China right now.....etc etc), and offer a simple solution (get rid of the migrants/punish the foreign countries). Naturally a lot of people wants to have a simple solution to their problems, even if the solution offered doesn't actually solve anything.
In addition, left wing politics focus a lot on equality, the sharing of resources/opportunities. This is an easier sell during times of prosperity, when people have enough, they are more open to sharing. During times of instability and economic hardship though, voters are more keen to focus on "what's mine is mine". Self preservation overcomes the generosity when your own lifestyle is in risk.
SOURCE: Osint


