Espionage Chronicles | Inside the KGB’s Deep-Cover Spy Family: How a Father Recruited His Own Son
Ujasusi Blog Originals
About Espionage Chronicles
Espionage Chronicles is a new weekly feature on Ujasusi Blog where readers can expect meticulously researched stories—both past and recent—that uncover hidden episodes of intelligence, espionage, and tradecraft from around the world.
When 16-year-old Peter Herrmann sat down on a park bench in Lima, Peru, in the spring of 1974, he had no idea that his life was about to change forever. His father, Rudi, a German-Canadian filmmaker, leaned in with a calm but unsettling confession:
“I am not who you think I am. I am a Czech man named Dalibor Valoušek, and I work for the Soviet Union—for the KGB.”
That single revelation would unravel everything Peter thought he knew about his family, propel him into a world of Cold War espionage, and turn him into a reluctant recruit for one of Moscow’s most secretive spy programs.
The KGB’s Elite “Illegals” Program 🌍
Rudi Herrmann was no ordinary immigrant. Recruited by the KGB in 1955, he became part of the illegals program—Moscow’s most prestigious espionage unit. Unlike conventional spies operating under diplomatic cover, illegals were trained to live in the West under false identities, blending seamlessly into local communities.
Rudi was given the stolen identity of a dead German soldier and paired with his German teacher, Inge, who became both his partner in marriage and espionage. Together they posed as war-weary East Germans fleeing communism, eventually emigrating to Canada in 1962 and later to the United States. Cold War historians have extensively documented the KGB’s illegals program through sources such as the Mitrokhin Archive and studies by the Wilson Centre.
From running a German delicatessen in Toronto to cultivating contacts at IBM in New York, Rudi built the perfect cover. But behind the façade of middle-class suburban life, he maintained clandestine radio contact with Moscow and carried out assignments designed to infiltrate Western institutions.
A Childhood of Upheaval and Secrets 👦
For Peter, childhood was marked by constant relocations and a father who seemed impossibly strict. Comic books, rock music, and American pop culture were forbidden. Friendships were fleeting as the family moved from Germany to Canada, and then on to New York.
The only bright spots were summers spent travelling across Europe or on the road in America with his father. On those trips, Peter glimpsed a more human side of Rudi—one that felt like partnership rather than dictatorship. But the undercurrent of secrecy was always there, shaping his alienation from the world around him.
The Shocking Confession in Lima, 1974 ✈️
The family’s trip to Chile in 1974, ostensibly to promote one of Rudi’s films, doubled as intelligence-gathering after Pinochet’s coup against Salvador Allende. On the way back, in Lima, Rudi decided it was time to reveal the truth to his teenage son.
Not only did Rudi admit he was a KGB spy, but he also disclosed that Peter’s mother was one too. Then came the real bombshell:
“Would you be willing to become an intelligence officer like me?”
Peter, caught between loyalty and disbelief, nodded his assent. That single nod was swiftly relayed to Moscow. The KGB’s response was decisive: the family would travel to the Soviet Union that summer to begin Peter’s induction. Archival records confirm that Directorate S, the KGB’s illegals unit, experimented with second-generation recruits during this period.
Meeting the KGB in Moscow 🇷🇺
In the summer of 1974, Peter—still a teenager—was taken on a surreal journey. Smuggled aboard a Soviet freighter in Denmark, he arrived in Leningrad and was whisked to Moscow.
There, inside a Stalin-era skyscraper safehouse, he was grilled by Directorate S officers, trained in basic spycraft, and told bluntly that he now had no choice. If he refused, he could not return to the United States; he knew too much.
The KGB christened him Erbe—German for “the Inheritor.” Contemporary accounts of illegals’ training, such as those outlined in Christopher Andrew’s The Mitrokhin Archive, describe similar indoctrinations, often involving surveillance drills, invisible ink, and dead drops.
The Training of a Teenage Spy 🕵️♂️
Peter’s early tasks were relatively benign: observe left-leaning students at McGill University in Montreal, write discreet reports, and master invisible ink. But the pressure of living a double life weighed heavily.
He struggled with depression, even mailing his parents a disturbing drawing of himself hanging from a noose. Rudi dismissed it as a “college phase” and pressed on with his son’s training, teaching him dead-drop techniques in New Jersey and sending him to the Soviet Union for further orientation.
In Moscow, handlers introduced Peter to Marxist theory and Soviet grandeur—tours of Volgograd’s Motherland Calls statue, Lake Baikal, and the Moscow Metro. Yet even then, he felt detached. For him, it was less about ideology and more about pleasing his father.
From Recruitment to Rebellion ⚖️
By 1976, Peter had transferred to Georgetown University in Washington, DC, an ideal environment for a budding KGB recruit. He studied Arabic and sent occasional reports about classmates. But the strain grew unbearable. He told his father he needed a break, setting the stage for a dramatic twist.
At Penn Station that summer, as Peter ascended the escalator, he saw his father flanked by two men in suits. They weren’t fellow spies—they were the FBI.
The Double Game with the FBI 🇺🇸
The FBI had tracked Rudi for months. Instead of arresting him outright, they offered a choice: prison or cooperation as a double agent. Rudi, frustrated with Moscow’s unrealistic demands, agreed to work for the Americans while still communicating with the KGB. FBI records released under FOIA highlight similar cases where illegals were flipped and used as counterintelligence assets.
For Peter, this meant monthly meetings with handlers from both the FBI and CIA, who took him to restaurants and even theme parks. Though the deception continued, the family was now living in a dangerous balancing act—serving two masters.
Witness Protection and Reinvention 🛡️
By 1980, the FBI ended the charade. Rudi publicly confessed to his role as an illegal at a bizarre press conference, humiliating the KGB. Soon after, the family entered witness protection.
The Herrmanns became the Holars. Peter chose a new name—Elliot—signalling his desire to bury his past. He built a new life in California and later Washington, DC, working in IT, marrying, and raising children.
His father, Dalibor Valoušek, lived until 2017, still clinging to his communist ideals. His mother, Inge, passed in 2004. His younger brother struggled with health challenges, dying in 2015.
Looking Back After Half a Century 📖
When Shaun Walker tracked down Elliot Holar in 2019, he was initially reluctant to talk. But over time, he began to open up. For decades, few friends or family knew about his extraordinary past.
Now retired, Elliot reflects with ambivalence. He admires his father’s discipline but resents the choices forced upon him. Above all, he questions whether spies should ever have children.
“Fundamentally, that’s what it comes down to. I just don’t see why you thought being an illegal and having children was a good idea. All the other things that come up later—those are just consequences of that decision.”
Intelligence Insight 🔎
The story of Rudi and Peter Herrmann—alias Dalibor and Elliot Holar—highlights both the ambition and the flaws of Cold War espionage. The KGB’s dream of a second-generation illegal was ingenious but cruel, ignoring the psychological toll on children born into lies.
For intelligence historians, this case remains a rare glimpse inside the human cost of deep-cover operations. For Elliot, it is a reminder that survival sometimes means silence, reinvention, and a determination not to let the past define the future.
SUPPORT UJASUSI BLOG
Please consider becoming a paid subscriber.
You can also donate.