Last modified: 28.06.2022 12:51
The BND works in secret. The service only communicates its findings to the Federal Government and a few selected parliamentarians. Is this secrecy still up-to-date?
By Florian Flade, WDR
The Playmobil figure of a spy next to the desk, Star Wars posters on the wall in the office. In addition, number puzzles and pictures of the guard dogs. Every Wednesday there are also photos of the food from the canteen in Berlin-Mitte. On Instagram, the Federal Intelligence Service (BND) has been providing rare insights into the otherwise secretive authority for about a year. The name of the user account "bndkarriere" reveals what it is all about: The German foreign intelligence service advertises in social networks for personnel.
For this, the BND reveals the usual secrecy - at least a little bit. His actual work, however, the secret acquisition and evaluation of information from war and crisis zones, about terrorist networks, foreign governments and armies, about arms and drug trafficking, migration and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, remains classified information.
Former BND employees demand more transparency
In the meantime, however, there is a discussion about how secret the BND must actually be. And whether it might not be useful from time to time to make findings of the service accessible to the public. For example, situation pictures or analyses of the war in Ukraine.
Most recently, former BND employees of the Discussion Group Intelligence Services in Germany, an association of veteran intelligence officers, suggested this in an open letter. Under the headline "Dare more transparency and profile!" they demanded that the BND be given the opportunity to point out "global threats and risk factors" in public reports "without affecting foreign policy interests or secrecy interests worthy of protection." Similar to the case with the Office for the Protection of the Constitution with its annual reports.
Nothing should leak to the public
Every year, the BND writes several thousand reports for the German government. In addition, the BND president speaks weekly at the Chancellery, where the technical supervision of the service is located, on the intelligence situation (ND situation). There are interviews of the office management in the committees and bodies of the Bundestag, and even individual briefings for members of parliament. But all this is happening behind closed doors. Everything is secret, nothing should be made public.
"As a matter of principle, the BND only comments on operational aspects of its work and any findings to the Federal Government and the competent secretly meeting committees of the German Bundestag," is usually the prayer-wheel-like response of the service to press inquiries.
Other intelligence agencies publish information
In other countries, intelligence and assessments are certainly published. For example, in the USA, where in recent years, for example, analyses of the impact of climate change on national security or the possible origin of the new corona virus have been presented by the secret services.
And even in the run-up to the current war in Ukraine, the US government has repeatedly downgraded information from the secret services, such as satellite images, and made it available to the public via the media. Intelligence chiefs also appeared in public sessions of the US Senate and explained the assessment of Vladimir Putin's intentions and the course of the war.
The UK is also surprisingly open about the findings of the services. The British Ministry of Defence tweets daily the intelligence assessment of the military situation in Ukraine.
"Proliferation Report" was discontinued in 2001
In Germany, on the other hand, the public rarely learns anything about the BND's assessment of the global political situation. Public relations work has so far been limited to a few interviews with the BND leadership in the media. In addition, there has been a public hearing of the otherwise secret Parliamentary Control Committee (PKGr) of the Bundestag for a few years now. Once a year, the heads of the German secret services are interviewed by members of the Bundestag. Broadcast via live stream on the Internet. The spy chiefs now also have the opportunity to make a public statement.
However, there is no comprehensive report on the BND's intelligence goals and its findings, comparable to the annual report by the Office for the Protection of the Constitution. Only from 1997 to 2001 was there a regular publication of the BND on the subject of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction - the "Proliferation Report". However, the publication was discontinued after the US services made their findings on proliferation much more extensive and detailed in a separate report.
A lot of information is accessible anyway
Several former intelligence officials recently suggested that the BND could take an example from the earlier situation paper "Soviet Military Power," which the U.S. military intelligence agency DIA issued from 1981 to 1991. In it, the military capabilities of the Soviet Union were analyzed. The BND could put together something similar today without revealing too much of its methods, the ex-spies argue.
In any case, much information that used to be obtained almost exclusively by the military and secret services is now freely and easily accessible. By researching publicly available sources, called "Open Source Intelligence" (OSINT), in social networks, for example. Likewise, satellite images from commercial providers are now available in passable quality for almost everyone.
Thus, a source or the procurement of a certain information is often no longer decisive or in need of secrecy. It is more about interpretation and analysis. However, the BND also says that there is a risk that selective publications could give the impression that the service is a "political tool".
More transparency for more acceptance
The debate about loosening secrecy has been going on in the US for several years. One of the proponents of "declassification" (downgrading to German) is Avril Haines, the current Director of Intelligence in the Biden administration. She warned in a letter to U.S. lawmakers a few months ago that too much secrecy could even have a negative impact on national security.
According to Haines, intelligence information must be able to be passed on faster and more flexibly. And this between the authorities and services, but also in relation to the public. In order to be part of the public opinion-forming process - and to increase the acceptance and understanding of the work of the services in the population.
SOURCE (Translated from German)


