Question: Will October 7, 2023 remain recorded as Israeli September 11?
AYALON: In Israel, most people see these dramatic events as a new Yom Kippur War. Just two days ago we commemorated the 1973 attack. And what happened was very similar. The attack came as a complete surprise. And the reasons are probably the same. But I think in the long run, when we try to understand our history, the page of 2023 will seem much more serious. This attack will change the face of Israel. This is the first time since the creation of the Jewish state that hundreds of civilians have been massacred, murdered in their homes, on our territory.
It will take us years to understand the long-term impact caused by the horror and fear linked to these events. We use Yom Kippur terminology, but today the atmosphere is very different. We created a state to defend ourselves. We invested a huge amount of money to ensure that our army would be the strongest and most efficient. And it all collapsed on October 7, 2023. Most people no longer expect anything from our political leaders. But yes, we still expected something from our military commanders and it failed.
The Israeli government did not listen to the army's warnings?
First there was a huge failure by our security agencies. All intelligence in Gaza was based on electronic surveillance. But the leaders of the military wing of Hamas, like their leader, Mohammed Deïf, survived the first and second Intifada and numerous Israeli military operations. They know how to communicate without telephone or internet. A very small number of officials were probably aware of the operation on their side. Our services have been indiscriminate.
Furthermore, a large part of the responsibility obviously lies with the government. The commanders of all security organizations told him that the policy being pursued was wrong and that it was obvious that it would be used by our enemies. Our enemies see us weakening and they see our resilience and unity weakening. They perceived a moment of great division around the crisis caused in the country by justice reform. Of course, the politicians didn't listen. Especially regarding the warnings about the West Bank. The Israeli government has done everything to ensure that Fatah and the Palestinian Authority are no longer a partner, because they have given power to Hamas.
This attack will change the face of Israel. This is the first time since the creation of the Jewish state that hundreds of civilians have been massacred, murdered in their homes, on our territory.
Today we have Hamas in Gaza and we have no one left in the West Bank. Most Palestinians, even in the West Bank, view the Palestinian Authority, and particularly its leader, Abu Mazen, as a collaborator with Israel. We have tolerated the intolerable by letting Hamas arm itself on our doorstep since 2006. We let Qatar transfer funds to it, which allowed it to arm itself. We managed the Hamas problem through periods of military offensives, followed by truces. Each time Hamas was a little stronger. Our government thought the main problem in Gaza was economic and gave some breathing space by issuing work permits to thousands of Palestinians, who entered our territory two weeks before the October 7 attack. Hamas is a very structured organization, Hamas is an ideology and Hamas is a social movement. We must fight the military wing of the movement, the Ezzeddine al-Qassam Brigades. We must ensure that there will no longer be this immense military capability on our doorstep. This requires a huge military operation.
Is a ground operation inevitable in Gaza?
Yes, we have no choice to destroy the Ezzeddine al-Qassam Brigades. But we should completely change our policy in order to create a Palestinian partner. We must say from the start that our war is not against the Palestinian people. Our war is against the military wing of Hamas. Before we even attack, we should say that we want to create a reality in which we will talk with the Palestinians, who accept the peace initiatives and who want to discuss with us the reality of two states. But I believe that no Israeli government will agree to do this today. Yet if we do not do so, we will see an increase in violence. Even today, Israel refuses to admit that the Palestinians are a people. Economic development does not will not be enough. They want freedom, they want to see an end to the occupation.
Do you believe that the events of the weekend would have been avoided if the Palestinian question had been resolved with the creation of a Palestinian state?
It's obvious. Look, our concept of security in Israel. Until the Yom Kippur War 50 years ago, we preferred land to peace because peace was not important to us. Our goal was safety. We had to wait for the shock of the Yom Kippur War to reach the conclusion that to have security, there must be peace. We achieved peace with Egypt only because of the trauma of Yom Kippur and we started negotiating with the Palestinians in Madrid and then Oslo only because of the first Intifada. Finally, we left Lebanon only because of Shiite terror and suicide bombings. We withdrew from Gaza only because of the second Intifada. The international community has played a major role in all the cases I have mentioned. Today we are experiencing a tragedy and no one cares. We can't blame anyone. No one can save us despite ourselves.
What about the Arab world? Is this the end of the Abraham Accords?
Nothing is completely dead. But above all, our problems are not dead. It's amazing to see the difference between what we saw when we signed the Abraham Accords and what the Arab world saw there. They signed the treaties to stop the immediate annexations planned by Netanyahu. It was a condition. Our government said yes and then explained to our public that we had not paid a price for peace. He explained that we would not proceed with annexations right away, but step by step. And so we don't keep our word.
Is the ground offensive a trap for Israel?
It will be very difficult. I know that to achieve this, we will have to kill thousands of Palestinians. I have no idea how many Israeli soldiers and how many Israeli civilians will die. I also know that the more Palestinians we kill in Gaza, the higher the chances of Hezbollah intervention in the north of the country. And that the level of terror in the West Bank will increase. What will happen in the Arab streets in Jordan, in Egypt… There are a lot of unknowns.
But Hamas's military capabilities must be eliminated, because today we find ourselves in a very difficult situation, where the deterrent effect of our forces has been greatly discredited. We have seen something in the last two days that we could not have imagined. It was a massacre. Children and women killed in their homes and not just by guns. And to destroy the military wing of Hamas, there is no alternative to the ground offensive, because we cannot kill 2 million people under bombardment.



