Who supervises the supervisors?
Last modified: 05.02.2023 18:00
The worldwide wiretapping operations of the Federal Intelligence Service (BND) have been monitored by a new authority for a year now. How does the Independent Control Council work?
By Manuel Bewarder and Florian Flade, WDR/NDR
On the extensive grounds in the Berlin district of Lichterfelde-West there used to be a Prussian barracks. Later, the Wehrmacht moved in, after the Second World War the US military. Today, behind a brick wall, there is a branch office of the Federal Intelligence Service (BND). But the spies now have lodgers.
In a small brick building, the former horse stable, a group of six men and women meets regularly. What they discuss there is one of the best kept secrets in the country. Since the beginning of 2022, the former judges of the Independent Control Council (UK Council), a new supreme federal authority, have been reviewing the BND's technical surveillance measures, i.e. how the foreign intelligence service searches worldwide telephone, Internet or satellite communications.
The public has not yet noticed much of the new control body. The authority management does not give interviews so far, only recently there is a rather sparse website. Probably there is no such powerful and at the same time little-known authority. And soon, according to research by WDR, NDR and "Süddeutsche Zeitung" (SZ), the UK Council could get more tasks.
Within the Federal Government, the considerations are maturing according to which the panel of judges should in future not only control the technical operations of the BND, but also the area of human sources. Then the inspectors would monitor, for example, how the BND recruits and leads informants worldwide. In addition, the Council could soon also be responsible for the protection of the constitution.
So far more of a temporary solution
The discussion comes up against an authority that is still in a provisional state. The Control Council will have around 60 employees; We are not only looking for lawyers, but also IT experts and political scientists. The headquarters of the independent authority, which is not subordinate to any ministry, is currently located in Berlin's government district.
Soon, however, a move will take place, because the premises are not considered tap-proof. That's why the top-secret meetings are currently still taking place on the BND grounds in the southwest of Berlin. Sometimes the inspectors have to commute between the locations several times a day.
Specification from Karlsruhe
After the revelations of former NSA employee Edward Snowden, the German government initially tried to improve the control of the secret services in Germany with small course corrections. In spring 2020, however, the Federal Constitutional Court made it clear that the review must be much more comprehensive. The wiretapping operations had to be approved in advance.
In a few months, a new law was written, with the UK Council as a major innovation. In mid-2021, the now 63-year-old Josef Hoch was sworn in as president, former judge at the Federal Court of Justice, previously chairman of the Berlin Court of Appeal. And then everything happened pretty fast. The BND explained its work to Hoch and his team in briefings, then the test operation began. Since 1 January 2022, the BND's Technical Intelligence (TA) has no longer been allowed to monitor communications without the Council's OK.
Workflow is in place
This "legalization" has led to the fact that there is now something like a template for approval. First of all, there is the German government, which every six months names topics or regions in its secret mission profile that are to be clarified by the BND. The service then reports, for example, telephone numbers, e-mail addresses or simply search terms for which the Internet or radio should be searched. Each order must be written down by the BND leadership. The worldwide data filter is of great importance for the service: About half of the approximately 500 reports created daily at the BND come from the TA department.
Every Tuesday, the UK Council meets to discuss the measures, often for many hours. For urgent cases, there is an emergency service. The auditors are allowed to inspect files, files and the technology of the BND. They have access to the secret service offices and access to computers and servers at all times. At least every six months, the Council must also report to the Parliamentary Control Committee (PKGr) in the Bundestag.
Foreign requests must also be approved
Within a short time, the entire roadworthiness test had to be rebuilt so that it could be traced by the new inspectors. By the end of 2022, all measures taken so far had to be written down and submitted to the Council - otherwise they would have had to be stopped immediately. For BND personnel, the administrative burden has thus increased significantly.
The new Control Council also oversees one of the most sensitive areas: the surveillance operations that the BND carries out for other intelligence services. The US eavesdropping service NSA or the British GCHQ transmit target acquisitions, so-called selectors. The BND, in turn, enters these search terms into its systems. These selectors must now also be justified and approved by the Control Council.
Always a balancing question
It is therefore a balancing act between efficiency and legal certainty. To paralyze the service, however, is by no means the goal, it is said from the environment of the UK Council. Don't think of yourself as a troublemaker. Rather, one is a servant, not a shaper of the law. And soon the work as a servant could become more extensive. The reason for this is a ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court on the Bavarian Protection of the Constitution Act. The state also has to control the domestic intelligence services more strictly.
So far, the G10 Commission has been responsible for approving surveillance at home and German nationals abroad. The name refers to Article 10 of the Basic Law. It is about the secrecy of telecommunications. The commission consists of about a handful of members who meet every few weeks in the Bundestag. It is not a full-time job, the Commission works on a voluntary basis. So could the new UK Council also take over their role?
According to reports, the government has not yet reached an agreement on this. The Federal Ministry of the Interior was mostly satisfied with the G10 Commission - the members almost always agreed to wiretapping measures. Even with an enlargement of the Commission, the requirements from Karlsruhe could probably be met. The Ministry of the interior therefore does not want to commit itself yet: "A closer and final assessment will take place in the ongoing votes," said a spokeswoman.
SOURCE (Translated from German)


